I think I found it. It was marked "Aragon," but it looked exactly like your pictures. I'm going to assume it was the Aragon II.
Forgive me if this sounds nasty, since that's not my intention, but if those shoes feel nicer and less plasticky than your Clarks Chilton Lace, the mind boggles at the suckfulness of the Clarks.
(Dagnabbit! I just realized that there was a Clarks store in the same shopping center as the Johnston & Murphy store. I could kick myself for not stopping by the Clarks store and seeing what the Chilton Lace shoes are actually like.)
But, once again, if the shoes appeal to you stylistically, and fit you well, go ahead and wear them. I wear various items which would receive little love here on SF (Brooks Madison fit suits, an Old Navy pea coat, corrected leather Bass Leavitt penny loafers, etc.), and I'm sure I'm not the only one.