newbie369: I don't like them very much.
1: Well, they are not terrible in terms of the squaredness (even a word?), but too square for my liking.
2: Well, I think they look quite bad. The leather seems to be of low quality from what I can tell and they are not pleasing to the eye.
I would say replace them, but if you don't want to use money on new shoes that is totally acceptable.
In my opinion, Herring Knightsbridge is a decent cap-toe oxford shoe that is quite reasonably priced. But given its low price other decent alternatives should be available in the same price range. Herring Churchhill is of a better quality, but somewhat more expensive.