or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Ask A Question, Get An Answer... - Post All Quick Questions Here (Classic menswear)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Ask A Question, Get An Answer... - Post All Quick Questions Here (Classic menswear) - Page 803

post #12031 of 33127
Quote:
Originally Posted by Unrefinery View Post


Everything you picked goes together well, and there's nothing wrong with black, but that particular coat is terrible.


Just curious and hoping to learn something here. Why do you say it's terrible? 

 

post #12032 of 33127
What kind of buttons should I put on a:

- forrest green double-breasted sportcoat.
- navy suede sportcoat.
- worsted olive sportcoat.
- light gray sportcoat.


I'm thinking the following:

- forrest green = gold buttons.
- navy suede = leather buttons.
- worsted olive = gold buttons.
- light gray = silver buttons.

Opinions and suggestions needed!
post #12033 of 33127
Quote:
Originally Posted by dah328 View Post

What kind of answer are you looking for? The black jacket goes less badly with those choices of shirt, tie, and trouser than it would with some other choices though less well than a navy blazer would.

So navy would be better?
post #12034 of 33127
Quote:
Originally Posted by wannabe View Post

What kind of buttons should I put on a:
- forrest green double-breasted sportcoat.
- navy suede sportcoat.
- worsted olive sportcoat.
- light gray sportcoat.
I'm thinking the following:
- forrest green = gold buttons.
- navy suede = leather buttons.
- worsted olive = gold buttons.
- light gray = silver buttons.
Opinions and suggestions needed!

Dark brown horn
Dark brown horn
Dark brown horn
Light brown horn

Leave the gold and silver buttons to blazers if you like them.
post #12035 of 33127
Quote:
Originally Posted by KObalto View Post

Dark brown horn
Dark brown horn
Dark brown horn
Light brown horn
Leave the gold and silver buttons to blazers if you like them.

+1... this is good.
post #12036 of 33127
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gerry Nelson View Post

425

Just curious and hoping to learn something here. Why do you say it's terrible? 

Overall it looks like a dated old man's jacket, like you'd see on veteran newsman Charles Gibson or something. Some of the details that contribute to this include:
  • Button point is way too low.
  • Lapel notch is too big and too low. Modern jackets have a small notch up at the collarbone.
  • Baggy around chest.
  • Too long overall.

The last two items might have something to do with how it rather poorly fits the model, but you get the idea.

Again I should stress that I like your colour palette and would encourage you to not switch to a navy blazer, which is (quite literally) the most unimaginative option possible.
post #12037 of 33127
Quote:
Originally Posted by KObalto View Post

Dark brown horn
Dark brown horn
Dark brown horn
Light brown horn
Leave the gold and silver buttons to blazers if you like them.

Would this make the jackets distinguishable as sportcoats? I've seen brown horn on suits around SF.
post #12038 of 33127
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gauss17 View Post

Does this work? Or is it too much navy?

Actually, it just occurred to me that the case can be made much more succinctly by simply juxtaposing the coat and the jeans to show what happens when these badly paired colours meet.

399

You're welcome.
post #12039 of 33127
Quote:
Originally Posted by wannabe View Post

Would this make the jackets distinguishable as sportcoats? I've seen brown horn on suits around SF.

that's true and not neccesarily....
post #12040 of 33127
Quote:
Originally Posted by Unrefinery View Post


Overall it looks like a dated old man's jacket, like you'd see on veteran newsman Charles Gibson or something. Some of the details that contribute to this include:
  • Button point is way too low.
  • Lapel notch is too big and too low. Modern jackets have a small notch up at the collarbone.
  • Baggy around chest.
  • Too long overall.
The last two items might have something to do with how it rather poorly fits the model, but you get the idea.
Again I should stress that I like your colour palette and would encourage you to not switch to a navy blazer, which is (quite literally) the most unimaginative option possible.


Thanks for that. Just to clarify, I wasn't the person who asked the original question but your points still hold :)

 

post #12041 of 33127
Quote:
Originally Posted by wannabe View Post

Would this make the jackets distinguishable as sportcoats? I've seen brown horn on suits around SF.

Yes. You have also seen them on plenty of sport coats on SF.
post #12042 of 33127
Quote:
Originally Posted by netsua View Post

Hi, I'm thinking of purchasing a pair of RL Darltons as my oneshoe. I'm a little concerned about the sizing. I hear they fit about a half size too big? I usually wear a size 10 US in most shoes. Does size 9.5 sound right?
bump.
post #12043 of 33127
does this look like a classically styled coat? lapes too big or no?

451
post #12044 of 33127
Quote:
Originally Posted by makewayhomer View Post

does this look like a classically styled coat? lapes too big or no?
451

Looks ok to me.
post #12045 of 33127
^ They look fine.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Ask A Question, Get An Answer... - Post All Quick Questions Here (Classic menswear)