Quote:
Originally Posted by
Fatto_in_Italia 
Funny discussion going on here.
Lefty and why, what you are saying makes sense. A calorie deficit is the trick (sounds easy) to lose weight. Now it doesn't matter how you achieve that, eat less, or exercise more.
However, couldn't it be, that some diets just make it easier on you? For example, eating food that give you more energy in stead of storing it immediately and make you lame and actually wanna hang out on the couch the rest of the day.
It doesn't change your point of the need for a calorie deficit, but it just shows that there are easier ways to lose weight than by stuffing yourself with junk food..
The key to any diet is sticking to it. If eating "clean" allows to stay on your diet longer, than that's the one for you. If, as in my case, you like "junk food" a lot and can work it into your calorie deficit successfully, then that's the best way. And for what's it's worth i get a lot more energy from a box of Capt'n Crunch than a box of oatmeal.
Strip down popular diet books to their basics and you'll see two fundamental things:
1) the psychology of sticking
2) massive calorie deficits
Everything else is just filler.
lefty