Going to pull this thread out of the grave but I could use some suggestions on real dress shoes, too. The only caveat (and very, very limiting factor) is my size: I'm a US 6-6.5D in an AE PA. So far I've managed to scavenge ebay/B&S for Park Ave's, AE Chester (though in a 7, so slightly big, but ok once or twice a week at work), and a pair of Alden monstraps in pebble grain. The brogues were pretty beat up when I bought them, but I nursed them back to a decent state (I think I paid $50 for them).
I want to get a pair of brown shoes, and although I don't mind getting the Park Aves again, it'd be nice if someone can suggest other good shoe brands that make my size. I've looked into Loake, which are reasonably priced, but can't seem to find anything in my size.