I have ordered two pairs and will follow-up after I pick them up. laffiar.com
Shoes are MTM. I ordered Balmoral Goodyear in black and Bolongnese loafers in tan.
They have many styles as examples in the store in various colors, leather and finishes. They were ok with changing some styles to other leathers that I saw on shoes, while certain shoes seemed to be more limited.
After picking style and colors, the cobbler (leather apron-clad) comes into the shop to measure. Measuring comprises trying on a couple of shoes in similar styles and sizes, tracings of your feet, and measurements made with a tape including length, across the ball of your foot, wrapped around the ball (two places) and then wrapped around your instep (two places).
Shoes will be ready in three weeks.