Originally Posted by Manton
I find it hard to believe that someone will judge the fit of a shirt from self posed pics, taken in a mirror, with an arm raised, based solely on the how the shirt looks on that raised arm. If poses like that are routine for you, and you are most concerned about looking good so posed, then I guess I can understand it.
I can also understand that, on the Internet, everyone has to find some fatal flaw in something someone else posts. I find it perverse, but I am aware that it is a fact of life.
BTW, you have now ignored -- three times -- my explanation. The shirt you praised is identical to the shirt you bashed. How do you explain that? I offered my explanation. What's yours?
isn't it just part of styleforum that people post pics of themselves and someone chimes in with "your pants are too long" or "those lapels are too narrow for your shoulders." people don't normally take these as attacks. how is my comment any different? if your sleeve falls like that in these pics it also likely falls when you put glasses on, when you put your hand to your chin, when you put a fork to your mouth, etc...
the simple answer to your explanation is that your measurements are such that your sleeve might look good, some of the time or most of the time, but they are incorrect as far as insuring
that your shirt stays in place. if i were you i would take that set of pictures to your shirtmaker and say, "how can we tweak my measurements so that i always look like the last picture?"