Actually, I wear the golf shirt the same way, buttoned to the top, I am not sure why, but always have. As for the in-shape part and the fit, I think I pull it off decently, not quite as well as Tiger mind you, but I am pretty fit. I like to wear the Ballin Gabardine Wool Pants, with say a nice Antigua golf shirt and Vest...I just do not dress in sport coat and suits on a very regular basis. In the neighborhood and social circles I travel in, it seems the more business casual golf look has become the tradition in the Atlanta area more. Edit here: Bradford I agree about the regionalism, and also on the Bobby Jones, there once was an outlet in Wisconsin you could get good deals through, but that has all but dried up. I do not care much for the Cutter & Buck, they are very wide cut for me, and also heavy, in the south the humidity is too high for their weight.