stephen - I'm too skinny for XL in most brands except the ones I mentioned above
Arcane - I think the biggest differences in sizes with W+H is seasonal, not V-neck versus U-neck. I own several U-necks from different seasons and they are sized slightly differently.
nyf - good call with S2A, I forgot to mention them. I have two S2A shirts, one is large, one is XL. I would disagree with Abercrombie, D&G or Armani. The OP mentioned he was lean and athletic and those brands tend to lean more towards buff guys.
Arcane - I think the biggest differences in sizes with W+H is seasonal, not V-neck versus U-neck. I own several U-necks from different seasons and they are sized slightly differently.
nyf - good call with S2A, I forgot to mention them. I have two S2A shirts, one is large, one is XL. I would disagree with Abercrombie, D&G or Armani. The OP mentioned he was lean and athletic and those brands tend to lean more towards buff guys.





