I like long shirts when they're not just part of a Hypebeast look (joggers, side-zip shirts, hype sneakers, etc). Tender one could be kind of cool. Recently saw a girl wearing the Beekeeper's shirt that I thought looked really good (although, I suppose hat's more like a jacket?).
Anyway, Frank, I think the one with the collar looks better. FWIW, if that's like Tender's other shirts, it's not so much "long" as it is just "oversized."