I'm looking at some Sutors as well (no croc...me=small timer). How do most of their calf and suede balmorals fit? True to size? FWIW I'm a 12B or 12C in Alden Barrie, 12.5C in Leydon/Plaza, and I have a pair of Kent Wang benchgrade captoes in a 12D that fit pretty well. Safe to say I'd be a 12US/11UK in most Sutors?
Sole measurements aren't always indicative of the fit, they can vary greatly depending on the last and the type of welt. For instance a shoe with a 360 welt will probably have a longer sole measurement than another shoe with a 270 welt, even if they are the same size. I'd be more interested in hearing from people who have worn the shoes and can give a review of the fit.