My first post was vague, so I'll elaborate. Look at all the different shoes he has for sale - while many of them are described incorrectly (i.e. YSL Rive Gauche for Gucci?), they all vary quite a lot in shape and leather, as well as details. Generally, fakers don't have the same qualities this seller has shown in their auctions. For example, those Gucci's have channeled soles. Fakers also usually tend to display a ton of different items from different "designers" that all look very similar. I think they are pretty nice looking shoes, all other points aside. The finish is very professional looking as well.