Originally Posted by infiniti029
I'm 5'7", medium build. Just to add to the list...
- Charles Tyrwhitt slim fits - A better fit than most, shoulders a bit wide for me, had the sleeves altered to 32".
- Jcrew Slim Fits - From what I heard, it can be a good fit for shorter/slimmer guys, will need to go to the store to try them out
- Lands End slim/tailored fit - Their "slim" fits were not a very good cut, and pretty boxy. The tailored fit dress pants were still pretty large proportionally.
Lands end have great quality shirts for the money, but even their tailored fit is very large in the shoulders. I would not recommend them if you are looking for slim shirts.
TM Lewin and CT shirts seem better in the chest/waist, but also have rather wide shoulders. (15.5 collar slim fit shirts have 18.5" shoulders - I need closer to 17.5" shoulders).
The slimmest off-the-rack shirts I've found have been H&M (bad quality though), Express modern/tailored fit, DKNY slim fit shirts, and Brooks Brothers Extra Slim Fit.