Styleforum › Forums › Lifestyle › Health & Body › Question about huge price discrepancy with Bel Ami by Hermes
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Question about huge price discrepancy with Bel Ami by Hermes

post #1 of 5
Thread Starter 
Today I went to the official Hermes Paris headquarters store in Toronto. I looked around and saw that the Bel Ami product was not on display in the store. The sales guy near me was selling a rug or something to a woman. So I waited until he had a moment then asked him if his store sold Bel Ami. He took a few seconds to think about it then was enthusiastically said "Yes, we do have Bel Ami. Do you want to to try it?" I said "Yes". Then he went into a closed drawer behind the counter out of view of the public eye and pulled out a bottle of Bel Ami, then took a piece of cardboard paper and put one spritz on it and gave it to me. Then he stashed the Bel Ami back into the drawer.

I asked him how much it costs, and he said $149. I was shocked because I was looking at online prices of it last night and I saw prices for the same thing that he claimed was $149, being listed online for between $40-60 CAD or USD (which is supposed to be less valuable than CAD at the present time). I was so shocked that I had to ask again just to be sure I had heard right so I said "The price is $149 right?" and he said "Yes".

This got me wondering, are the online bottles counterfeit imitations (seems unlikely since a wide variety of websites have that price range...). Otherwise, who in their right mind would pay $149 for something that can be bought for $40-60?

Is the Hermes store just way over-priced? Isn't that kind of unethical of them to be padding their prices by such a crazy margin?

I'm also wondering: how come the Hermes store doesn't put Bel Ami on display, yet they did put a lot of their other cologne products on display?
post #2 of 5
Bel Ami is not something that is especially in demand. Maybe they ran out of the retail bottles and just had the tester sitting behind the counter. Not sure what the retail price in Canada is but it is available from Hermes USA online store for $110. You should be able to get it from a reputable online retailer for much less than $110.
post #3 of 5
Thread Starter 
I am pretty sure I saw him take the Bel Ami out of a Bel Ami box before he did the spritz. Should testers be in a box like that? Actually that is something that shocked me too, because I was wondering if he just opens a random Bel Ami bottle and spritzes that for anyone who wants to try it. Would that be something that is illegal to do, to sell bottles that have been spritzed on the cardboard paper as new?

I'm sure they had lots of Bel Ami stock though, otherwise he woulda told me they only had a tester in stock, right?

They had a Terre bottle as the tester on the counter, that was the only tester that was visible though.

How come Bel Ami isn't in demand, is that because it's bad? The reason I looked into it was because I read a thread on this site that said it was good and lasts really long.

I spritzed two spritzes of the Terre tester onto my palm and wrist, but the scent was totally gone two hours later. Is that normal? Would other eau de toilettes last longer than that with just two spritzes, or no?
post #4 of 5
Quote:
Originally Posted by stylemeup View Post
the official Hermes Paris headquarters store in Toronto.

You're paying for the real estate, not the product.
post #5 of 5
^^ yep.

The thing about Bel Ami is that it's been on the market for a long time (decades) now and it's no longer the current style (i.e. dry and spicy). Hermes has newer, more exclusive products out there, and Bel Ami's price has fallen accordingly. Can say the same for Caron Yatagan, another favorite of mine.

Of course, Hermes also recognizes that people who walk into their stores for the most part aren't budget-conscious, so they'll price their goods however they like.

As far as counterfeits, I'm not seeing it. Far easier and more lucrative to fake Creed and Chanel.

You can see similar cases of arbitrage with Guerlain Vetiver. Sephora: $85. Scentiments $30-ish.

This may vary by manufacturer, but tester boxes tend to be different from the normal packaging. That said, I've had retail boxes opened for me when I wanted to sniff something, no objections on either side of the counter, since for a spray there's no diluting or altering the product, there's just a smidge less in the bottle than there was earlier and frankly I so seldom finish a bottle of anything I almost welcome the head start, meager as it is.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Health & Body
Styleforum › Forums › Lifestyle › Health & Body › Question about huge price discrepancy with Bel Ami by Hermes