Caribbean Cask is good at around $50 if you can find it for that. It can go up to about $75 and it's not worth that in my opinion.
I Just Bought a... (Wine, Spirit, or Beer) - Page 120
The brandy was really good at Le Lion.
Laphroiag 3x 0.33l for 51€. Very good deal, normally the big bottles are 40-50€/liter. Good way to try the Laphroiag lineup.
Someone in this thread once asked about Campari alternatives for the Negroni -- I know AC is a big fan of Gran Classico, which I have never tried. Using Luxardo Bitter was suggested to me as sublime, and it almost is, except for the minty-menthol thing it has going on. Its the very same thing I can't deal with in Fernet. So, I don't enjoy it, but you might.