I think it gets too close to costume, but I've never worn a tie bar/clip so I'm perhaps not the best judge.
I wear one every day, and I think the propeller is a little silly. Actually, the one I like best is the one in the upper pic, but that does not appear to be on offer.
They seem to cut against the free flowing looks of today. Sometimes they can have a certain youthful, retro chic like a thin tie paired with a short sleeved shirt for that hipster/office look.
Unless long enough, they only seem to work with narrow ties. Even when long enough, they leave an indentation in the silk which needs to be steamed out (thats is, if it doesnt crush the pile permanently)
sorry if this is considered thread jacking, but what about tie pins? i have an antique tie pin that my great grandfather gave me, and i like it a lot.
You mean tie tacks? Things that stick through the tie and pin it to the shirt? Or collar pins, a pin that pulls together the two sides of the shirt collar under the tie knot?
As to the former, I see no point with a four in hand tie. Maybe if you are trying for an antique look. They make sense with billowing formal ascots, but when are you going to wear those?
As to the latter, they can be very nice but they are "fussy" and noticable. A true pin, as opposed to a bar put through two eyelet holes in the collar, will rough up the collar over time.
You mean tie tacks? Things that stick through the tie and pin it to the shirt? Or collar pins, a pin that pulls together the two sides of the shirt collar under the tie knot?
As to the former, I see no point with a four in hand tie. Maybe if you are trying for an antique look. They make sense with billowing formal ascots, but when are you going to wear those?
As to the latter, they can be very nice but they are "fussy" and noticable. A true pin, as opposed to a bar put through two eyelet holes in the collar, will rough up the collar over time.
well mine is a pin with a back and then there is a chain that attaches to the button. I haven't had any problems with it ruining any ties