or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Menswear Advice › Lapel Button Hole - Cross Stitching in X Pattern Across - Keep it?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Lapel Button Hole - Cross Stitching in X Pattern Across - Keep it?

post #1 of 7
Thread Starter 

I have searched and searched and have yet to see anything similiar! 

 

Was the designer's idea behind this stitched shut (via an x cross pattern over it) lapel button hole (boutonniere) to be left as is? It is a Thomas Pink Wool Blazer with pink stitching on one of the cuff button holes. This "x" stitching across the lapel button is also pink. 

 

I do like the cross stitching done over this lapel button hole, but am wondering if the design behind it was to allow someone the choice to keep it. While I have seen many sewn shut, I've never seen a lapel button like this. Thoughts? 

 

Keep it? Take it out? Agree that some (less conservative) would choose to keep it in? 

 

post #2 of 7

Don't be absurd. Remove it as you would any basting stitch. :crazy:

post #3 of 7
Quote:
Originally Posted by smittycl View Post
 

Don't be absurd. Remove it as you would any basting stitch. :crazy:

 

Pretty sure he doesn't know that it's basting stitching.  

 

@dreamacast, it is not there to stay.  It's supposed to be removed.

post #4 of 7
Thread Starter 


Thanks for replying. That was the specific concern... remove it as I would any other? Clearly the stitching on the vents and shoulders I removed, but had never seen such baste stitching on a lapel button. Not familiar with the sewing process, I wondered why a sewn shut buttonhole would have this stitching. I didn't realize (which I assume) is true that perhaps it's for the purpose of sewing the button shut? Still not sure of that. 

 

Regardless, I wondered if the designer (for right or wrong) intended the stitching in this case to remain as a statement of sorts. Further the fact that all other tacking was a different color thread, except this, which was a pink (coordinating with the single sleeve button hole contrast stitching). 

 

Thanks again.

post #5 of 7
Quote:
Originally Posted by dreamacast View Post


I wondered why a sewn shut buttonhole would have this stitching. I didn't realize (which I assume) is true that perhaps it's for the purpose of sewing the button shut? Still not sure of that. 

Thanks again.

It's possibly/probably a functional buttonhole. That being said, much of this stuff except at the top-end is purely marketing affectation to differentiate it visually from the sea of other jackets on a store shelf. I'd say that's probably the case here.

In general, though, lots of brands use basting in their own colors; Isaia for example has its bright red basting, Hickey Freeman uses gold/yellow, etc.

In any case, to echo what others have said... definitely remove it as you would a brand tag/label stitched onto the sleeve.
post #6 of 7
Thread Starter 


Thank you. That is a great explanation and makes sense. Particularly it certainly caught my attention walking by the jacket (albeit, I too have been a fan of Pink shirts in the past). Thank you again for your kind reply.

post #7 of 7
Quote:
Originally Posted by dreamacast View Post
 


Thanks for replying. That was the specific concern... remove it as I would any other? Clearly the stitching on the vents and shoulders I removed, but had never seen such baste stitching on a lapel button. Not familiar with the sewing process, I wondered why a sewn shut buttonhole would have this stitching. I didn't realize (which I assume) is true that perhaps it's for the purpose of sewing the button shut? Still not sure of that. 

 

Regardless, I wondered if the designer (for right or wrong) intended the stitching in this case to remain as a statement of sorts. Further the fact that all other tacking was a different color thread, except this, which was a pink (coordinating with the single sleeve button hole contrast stitching). 

 

Thanks again.

Sorry if I pounced on initial reply. :embar:

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Menswear Advice
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Menswear Advice › Lapel Button Hole - Cross Stitching in X Pattern Across - Keep it?