What's the style number?
Looks like the same one the Leeds are on, the 511, based on the bulbous toe.
What size are they? You can definitely buy a new pair and send those to me.
If those were mine, I would likely use a striping agent (saphir renomat/renovateur, AE conditioner cleaner) to remove that blotch and then polish over it with some walnut polish.
Speaking of...I was actually drinking some Buffalo Trace last night while creeping on @watchidiot's instagram. Amidst all the matching watches and MTO shoes, I came across a couple cookie pictures and pondered this question. I blame it on the alcohol
BT is great stuff, but my go to is Elijah Craig small batch, just incredible value for the money.
Blantons is awesome. Unfortunately, the liquor stores in NC never, ever have it. Oh how I wish for a free market liquor system.
A natty CXL Indy boot on a more tapered last.