What size are you? I have an 11D that may be my wrong size. Otherwise I think their semi-annual sale is coming up. I got mine last year from Nordstrom during their semi annual sale. Also,you can find many brand new pairs with box on eBay for ~200 which is practically stealing.
You could try an exchange at Nordstroms. They have a no questions asked return policy. Might be a little jerky after a long time, but its their policy.