or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread 2016 - News, Pictures, Sizing, Accessories, Clothing, etc
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread 2016 - News, Pictures, Sizing, Accessories, Clothing, etc - Page 295

post #4411 of 17674
Maiden voyage for my chili McGregors on cheap office carpet. Really glad I stumbled into the EE, would have been swimming in a EEE.

e093f10baf538fe6921f035649899ff1.jpg

2d9bff2e4844ad62760f9d310ee340ee.jpg

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk
post #4412 of 17674
Quote:
Originally Posted by bishopcraiga View Post

Maiden voyage for my chili McGregors on cheap office carpet. Really glad I stumbled into the EE, would have been swimming in a EEE.

 

Wait what?! How did you get McGregors in EE?

post #4413 of 17674
@BennJeff I'll offer my 2 cents since I actually tried on the lake forest orthotic at one point so I have some idea what you're talking about.
1. For a formal bal, id say go for a bloor st or hopkinson, PA and Carlyle and see which is best. Maybe start with 9E and go from there.

2. Disagree with the black. With charcoal lots of people would say chili - good choice. I prefer walnut - its more flashy and works well with shiny perorated captoes and wingtips. Oxblood would be my close 2nd.
post #4414 of 17674
Quote:
Originally Posted by AndyMiddles View Post

Quote:
Originally Posted by bishopcraiga View Post

Maiden voyage for my chili McGregors on cheap office carpet. Really glad I stumbled into the EE, would have been swimming in a EEE.

 

Wait what?! How did you get McGregors in EE?


Picked them up from the Jeffersonville outlet via the shoe bank. It was the only McGregor listed under 11EE. Figured since it's a blucher I'd try it even though my Park Avenues are 11 EEE.

c6a3eec570b8d87b9dd19aee8f770493.jpg

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk
post #4415 of 17674
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dd1101 View Post

My Cambridges in burgundy finally came in Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)









Those are mighty purty. They look almost black, is that just the lighting or are they really so dark?
post #4416 of 17674
Quote:
Originally Posted by bishopcraiga View Post


Picked them up from the Jeffersonville outlet via the shoe bank. It was the only McGregor listed under 11EE. Figured since it's a blucher I'd try it even though my Park Avenues are 11 EEE.

c6a3eec570b8d87b9dd19aee8f770493.jpg

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

I was trying to get McGregors in EE for quite some time but was told that they unfortunately did not make them in EE.  I would have to imagine that you got a pair that someone wasn't 100% happy with from a special size request order.  You are a lucky man!

post #4417 of 17674
Quote:
Originally Posted by ZheNewYork View Post

For any of you have Amex cards, there's a $50 for $250 AE coupon just popped up until June.

Thanks for pointing this out. I was just about to order something from Shoe Bank. With tax, I'm just under $200. I'm tempted to add one of the $67 pairs to my order as my net cost for the add-on item would be under $25. Anyone have experience with the Sandman slipper?



It's either that or some random bit loafer/boat shoe/driver that I could flip on eBay.
post #4418 of 17674
Quote:
Originally Posted by AndyMiddles View Post

Quote:
Originally Posted by bishopcraiga View Post


Picked them up from the Jeffersonville outlet via the shoe bank. It was the only McGregor listed under 11EE. Figured since it's a blucher I'd try it even though my Park Avenues are 11 EEE.

c6a3eec570b8d87b9dd19aee8f770493.jpg

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

I was trying to get McGregors in EE for quite some time but was told that they unfortunately did not make them in EE.  I would have to imagine that you got a pair that someone wasn't 100% happy with from a special size request order.  You are a lucky man!


Lucky indeed. I figure that is exactly what happened, but a slight eyelet misalignment, that I didn't even notice at first, and two small blemishes that will inevitably even out with wear weren't enough for me to be anything but giddy when the fit is so spot on. It is strange that they only did a regular size run on them. Why else would you put it on the 65?

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk
post #4419 of 17674

Choco suede Macneils the other day...

 

post #4420 of 17674
Quote:
Originally Posted by BennJeff View Post
 

Hey guys, 

 

Just wanted to run a few questions past you AE experts. I'm attending a wedding in roughly a month's time and suppose I need some new shoes to go with my suit. Currently the only pair of AEs that I own are some orthotics that I picked up a few years ago at Nordstrom Rack for cheap when I needed some shoes quickly for a function. They are in the Chili color and I believe are known as the "Lake Forest" from 2013. They are a 9.5 D and I find that they fit quite comfortably. My question I suppose is what do you think my sizing would be in other AE lasts? My foot is generally pretty flat but I've never thought of it being all that wide. Several pairs of AE I have tried on seemed to be too narrow for me though. We have an AE outlet near us which is most likely where I will purchase my shoes so any last help is appreciated so I would know what to tell them should they need to order a pair for me from another store. 

 

My 2nd question would be what AE colors do you guys think go well with a charcoal/dark charcoal suit? I know they classic would be black obviously, but black probably wouldn't fit into the rest of my wardrobe all that well. I'd prefer to find a shoe and color to wear with my suit but also that I would wear at other times with dark jeans or something since it's not everyday I have the need to wear a suit. Most people would probably tell me to just buy some beater shoes for the occasion but I have issues throwing money away on cheap shoes.

 

Cheers and thanks for any insight or help you can provide. 


I don't think this is a minority view at this point, but I love these kinds of questions and must display my overly inflated ego by putting my four cents in on the matter.

 

I mostly agree with the Count on this. Charcoal (if true charcoal and not mid gray which I often see labeled as such) is right next to black on the formality spectrum. Between that and jeans, you have less formal suits, conservative odd combinations, other odd combinations, slacks without a tie, chinos with a tie, and any number of other scenarios. don't try to find a double duty shoe for these two ensembles. In my opinion, you're going to be making a big compromise to choose one shoe to go with your suit and dark jeans. You are going to be getting a shoe that should really be worn with one or the other, or possibly one that really shouldn't be worn with either. Best case scenario, it doesn't immediately look wrong to the untrained eye. But, the trade off is that you are definitely going to be falling short of the best overall appearance of both ensembles, the suit and the more casual ensemble. I for one, wouldn't choose this option if I already had shoes that would look great with my jeans. Get the suit shoe and look your best when you wear that suit. After all, isn't that the point of having a dark suit in the first place –to present your best self?  

 

Also, I think your color choice for a true charcoal suit (charcoal trousers are a different animal) is going to be limited to black or burgundy (with a black sole). If the suit leans more toward med grey, I agree with others that you might go dark chili. If there are other combos in your normal wardrobe like chinos with a jacket or tie, you might consider a balmoral brogue, but otherwise, I would just recommend sticking with the black or merlot PA or the black FA. 

 

As for contemplating the purchase of the shoe and weighing costs, may I suggest thinking about it this way. What justified the expense of the suit? If you've invested a little money in a suit you expect to ensure that you are adequately outfitted for certain occasions, why not invest in a pair of shoes to go along with it? Regardless of how many wears you get out of the shoes, they are going to go with that suit perfectly every time you wear it. And if you didn't invest much in that suit, the shoes can definitely be worn with whatever your next conservative suit purchase is going to be, whether grey (whatever shade) or navy. Even if you only wear them an average of three times a year, you may realistically end up with plenty of wears over more than a decade to justify the present expense. In my opinion, if buying a conservative suit can be justified (which I believe to be the case for any man with the means in America to do so), then buying a proper pair of calf skin oxfords to accompany that suit is also justifiable. 

post #4421 of 17674
Quote:
Originally Posted by BennJeff View Post
 

Hey guys, 

 

Just wanted to run a few questions past you AE experts. I'm attending a wedding in roughly a month's time and suppose I need some new shoes to go with my suit.

I just went to a wedding as a guest this last weekend. It was held in a private house on the California central coast and was a very nice opportunity to shoe watch. I spotted one Alden, two AEs, neither of which was a Park Ave, and one guy with a really nice Italian loafer. Nearly everything else was a sea of unattractive shoes with rubber soles. A large number of apron and bicycle shoes. My take home was we on the SF are FAR more serious about appropriate footwear/clothing combinations than 95% of the people attending a very nice wedding. All of the groomsmen and the groom wore light gray canvas Vans sneakers. Philistines. A decent AE shoe, well polished, will put you in the upper 2% at most events.

post #4422 of 17674
Quote:
Originally Posted by Buster Brown View Post

Thanks for pointing this out. I was just about to order something from Shoe Bank. With tax, I'm just under $200. I'm tempted to add one of the $67 pairs to my order as my net cost for the add-on item would be under $25. Anyone have experience with the Sandman slipper? Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)

It's either that or some random bit loafer/boat shoe/driver that I could flip on eBay.

I have the Sandman and dig it. Super cozy. Well worth the $77 I paid, and about the same as an L. L. Bean shearling slipper.
post #4423 of 17674
Lexingtons with Dainite today because of the torrential rains.
post #4424 of 17674
I looked at the sandman when it came out but passed. I'm not a slipper guy. They seemed nice, soft, lightweight. They aren't USA made like the Banff but they also aren't narrow as shit, which is a big plus.
post #4425 of 17674
Quote:
Originally Posted by smfdoc View Post
 

I just went to a wedding as a guest this last weekend. It was held in a private house on the California central coast and was a very nice opportunity to shoe watch. I spotted one Alden, two AEs, neither of which was a Park Ave, and one guy with a really nice Italian loafer. Nearly everything else was a sea of unattractive shoes with rubber soles. A large number of apron and bicycle shoes. My take home was we on the SF are FAR more serious about appropriate footwear/clothing combinations than 95% of the people attending a very nice wedding. All of the groomsmen and the groom wore light gray canvas Vans sneakers. Philistines. A decent AE shoe, well polished, will put you in the upper 2% at most events.

 

Isn't this the truth.

 

My brother's wedding was last weekend and I spent quite a bit of time with my dad as he decided on a shoe to wear with his dark charcoal suit.  He ended up going with a dark chili Lexington from the shoebank, as he likes the derby style more than an oxford.  I explained to him the rules, just how everyone has been explaining them to @BennJeff but at the end of the day if you are wearing AEs, you are light years ahead of the crowd.  

 

IMO, if you aren't going to go with black or burg, he needs something dark chili or oxblood, which would both go well with dark denim.  I personally am OK with wearing most non-black dress shoes with jeans, but I understand why others here shy away from this.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread 2016 - News, Pictures, Sizing, Accessories, Clothing, etc