Lol, I was just talking about this in PM's with another member earlier this week. His photos really are terrible. Make everything look really bulbous in the front.
I picked up my merlot Hopkinsons from him for $85, with basically zero wear on them.
I bought it today in Oxblood. I can't see it working with a suit, but jeans all the way to business casual marks the sweet spot.
I like it.
I wear 8E for PA, Strand, and McAllister then 7.5E in Dundee 2.0 (Suede).
I tried various sizes in-store and found 8E works for me once again.
I have First Aves with and without shearling, in the same size. Fitment is similar. (And, I loved mine about 10 times this winter)