I think everyone should get the Midnight Blue, BUT be warned it is almost black in certain light. Don't be expecting Navy as it's not that. It's between black and Deep Navy blue. You can see it best in the contrast in my pic below. The first one is a Strand Midnight Blue, then in the Middle is the Cornwallis Midnight blue. They are often mistaken for black so I added blue laces which helps. The Neumok is more of a Navy IMHO. The Midnight blue is black with a hint of blue tint.