or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread 2016 - News, Pictures, Sizing, Accessories, Clothing, etc
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread 2016 - News, Pictures, Sizing, Accessories, Clothing, etc - Page 864

post #12946 of 17558

Loden Dundees today to end the workweek.

 

post #12947 of 17558


Brown McGregors, PRL tattersall twill estate shirt and BR herringbone pants for Friday.
post #12948 of 17558
Quote:
Originally Posted by Middlife View Post

You pushed me over the ledge with this picture. I just put in an order for a pair of these along with some grey suede Strandmoks. FBWs!

I am trying very hard to stay away from more wingtips. But I don't blame you for ordering as well. They look fantastic. Let's see how much willpower I have. Nice shoes @M635GUY !
post #12949 of 17558
Quote:
Originally Posted by cc808314 View Post
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Middlife View Post

You pushed me over the ledge with this picture. I just put in an order for a pair of these along with some grey suede Strandmoks. FBWs!

I am trying very hard to stay away from more wingtips. But I don't blame you for ordering as well. They look fantastic. Let's see how much willpower I have. Nice shoes @M635GUY !

 

FBWs exist on other threads too! An online buddy pointed me towards some new old stock Hanover long wings in my size on Ebay. They lasted for another 12 seconds and are now on the way. Did I need more wing tips? No. But this makes 6 pairs now, but I had nothing in this color range and I love vintage, made in USA, when that actually meant a quality product.

 

Warning: Spoiler! Non AE content, Shield eyes if necessary. (Click to show)
Warning: Spoiler! Non AE content, Shield eyes if necessary. (Click to show)
post #12950 of 17558
Quote:
Originally Posted by smfdoc View Post

FBWs exist on other threads too! An online buddy pointed me towards some new old stock Hanover long wings in my size on Ebay. They lasted for another 12 seconds and are now on the way. Did I need more wing tips? No. But this makes 6 pairs now, but I had nothing in this color range and I love vintage, made in USA, when that actually meant a quality product.
Warning: Spoiler! Non AE content, Shield eyes if necessary. (Click to show)
Warning: Spoiler! Non AE content, Shield eyes if necessary. (Click to show)

Haha, aren't we all? BTW, nice pick up. I have a thing for Vintage pairs, as well. Unfortunately, they are hard to come by in my size. I have only been able to get a Florsheim chili grain leather pair, and the #8 shells I picked up are a little big.
post #12951 of 17558

@ace13x

 

 

A comparison of profila binding.  Loakes vs. AE.   Not a totally fair comparison, because the Loakes are new, but I still think Loake puts a lot more attention to detail on it.

post #12952 of 17558
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lobster33 View Post

@ace13x





A comparison of profila binding.  Loakes vs. AE.   Not a totally fair comparison, because the Loakes are new, but I still think Loake puts a lot more attention to detail on it.

Yea that's my problem with AEs. All the top houses do profila and it looks good. And sure a JL, EG, or Vass is going to look perfect. But they really need to get it better if they do it. The Loakes binding here seems flush or almost above the outer, preventing the roughing you get on the carlyles. And the binding is just playing roller coaster with the edge there.

nice comparo. How are you liking the 1880 otherwise?
post #12953 of 17558
Lubbock got the call today. The blonde and "rough" cousin of Norwich. Happy Friday!

post #12954 of 17558
Quote:
Originally Posted by styleaudit91 View Post


nice comparo. How are you liking the 1880 otherwise?

 

I'd say they are about the same as AE overall -- I'm very pleased.  The footbed in the ball of the foot are harder on Loakes, but the heel is nicely cushioned.  I prefer AE's leather footbeds as they are a little softer. The tongues on Loakes are also thinner, which makes you feel the laces a little more.  I like AE tongues a little more.  Minor issues overall.  I think the detailing is slightly better on Loakes.  The Loake is also great if you have a high arch, but less great if you have a really skinny foot (Loakes run wider).  

post #12955 of 17558
Quote:
Originally Posted by cc808314 View Post

Lubbock got the call today. The blonde and "rough" cousin of Norwich. Happy Friday!

How do you like those? They sure look good with denim. Also, how do you find the sizing? I'm between the Norwich and Mora 2.0 as my favorite recent AE monk strap. I see a 9D brown calf Norwich on the Shoe Bank that might work. I have the Madison Park in 8.5D and I don't THINK an extra half size will ruin the fit. Just who knows what kind of shape it's in. Otherwise it's go with Mora 2.0 or save my money and wait for the brown shell Norwich seconds to go back on sale...  even though I don't see one of those in 8.5D.

post #12956 of 17558
Quote:
Originally Posted by cc808314 View Post

Lubbock got the call today. The blonde and "rough" cousin of Norwich. Happy Friday!


I've always liked the Lubbock, but it was already discontinued when I started buying AE. What last is it on anyway?
post #12957 of 17558
Quote:
Originally Posted by Newberry View Post




I've always liked the Lubbock, but it was already discontinued when I started buying AE. What last is it on anyway?

Pretty sure 222 is the last. Same as Norwich, Madison Park, Player's Shoe...  and obviously some others.

post #12958 of 17558
Quote:
Originally Posted by St Hubbins View Post

How do you like those? They sure look good with denim. Also, how do you find the sizing? I'm between the Norwich and Mora 2.0 as my favorite recent AE monk strap. I see a 9D brown calf Norwich on the Shoe Bank that might work. I have the Madison Park in 8.5D and I don't THINK an extra half size will ruin the fit. Just who knows what kind of shape it's in. Otherwise it's go with Mora 2.0 or save my money and wait for the brown shell Norwich seconds to go back on sale...  even though I don't see one of those in 8.5D.

As far as I know Madison Park is on 222 or maybe 108 last. The two lasts in my experience are similar, so I would guess 8.5D would be the best option. I would give 9D a shot, you never know. One thing to keep in mind is that with monk straps its a little difficult to make them tighter around the instep since you don't have laces. At least, that's what I have experienced. I really like the brown Norwich. I have a pair but can't wear because of incorrect size. They are very versatile - denim, chinos, thicker wool pants, heck you can probably pull them off even with regular wool pants.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Newberry View Post



I've always liked the Lubbock, but it was already discontinued when I started buying AE. What last is it on anyway?

222 last
post #12959 of 17558
Quote:
Originally Posted by Neo1 View Post
 

That's crazy f-ing annoying - I'd be pissed about that whole thing.  You definitely have a higher threshold than me for patience.  I hope someone from AE retail reads your thing.

 

If you can wait I'm with my engineering buddy and I'd order it again and see.  If you really can't, no way I'd take the messed up size thing - I'd have to go with the beat up one - maybe try to get something off.  Misized will always end up bad no matter how you slice it.

 

Agreed, @Neo1. Figured I was done dealing with the store and would order straight from the web site. Oops, not on sale anymore. So either a call to CS or a return/re-order from the store. Grrrr, my patience is running thin! Yes, it would be great if AE retail reads some of the groups concerns with QC of their products and the stocking of sizes at their retail locations. Especially when the concerns are coming from true champions of the brand.


Like many, my AE "track record" has been particularly problematic.

Rant/examples spoiled - in attempt to not take away from the 'appreciation' of the thread (Click to show)

I found an email exchange I had with Kelly in CS (who has always been nothing short of AMAZING and always takes care of me), where we discussed my returns. All were determined to be structural (not cosmetic, which I would live with, especially in 2nds) and replaced or refunded. That is great and all, but at some point you would think a discount/gift card would be in order for the inconveniences and trips to the post office.

 

-Fullerton developed cracks in heel of footbed [discontinued, so couldn't offer replacement]
-2 different Gobis had inch gaps between insole and back of shoe [replaced with a 3rd pair]
-Boulders had very different widths between left/right shoe [didn't even want to ask for a replacement]
-2 pairs of Bleecker Streets with uneven heels [replaced]
-Daltons had uneven heels [SA wouldn't wave the $10 restocking fee, so I didn't replace]
-2 Maritimes with hump in footbed [ended up keeping mismatched pair]

-Kirkwoods developed heavy, heavy creasing in 1 shoe only after first wear [replaced]

-All 4 versions of my Kirks/Maritimes have issue with staining my socks and the footbed overlay coming unglued and pulling out [kept them as this seems like issue with all these models]

-Frieburg had a divot in footbed [kept after Kelly encouraged me to wear them a few times with assurance I could return them worn, if needed]

 

And then the previously documented issues of my HM (had to order since no B widths in store / bad finishing on 1 boot / reorder / more wait time / fit isn't ideal / basically told that's what you get with hand lasted shoes). I'll update the latest with these in my next post.


Edited by middlepP - 9/16/16 at 6:09pm
post #12960 of 17558
Holy s&@t, I just looked at the Shoebank inventory for 9D and the availability is unbelievable. 4 pages of clearance shoes under $150. 2 colors of Shaker Heights for $127, that's unreal!

@St Hubbins , I see Norwich is priced $157. Last year they were down to $97. Talk to your SA.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Allen Edmonds Appreciation Thread 2016 - News, Pictures, Sizing, Accessories, Clothing, etc