In the 5 and 8 last, I wear 10.5 EEE. I check about once a day (since the obsession started). I think this has been the most at 58. Granted, that is without the Rutledge I just bought today. Some of them don't look bad at all, but the price is nowhere near some of the other steals I've been seeing.
I usually pay between $40-100 for good AE shoes on eBay. Some you win, some you lose. For instance the pair of vintage (82-83) Chesnutt Chesters that I wore today that had maybe 5-10 wears on them that I paid $40 for.
Or merlot Hopkinson for $85.
Malverns for $40.
Harrisons for $40.
Patience is the key. The hunt is my addiction and the better the deal, the better the fix.