At least when I calculated it, they were giving an extra shirt with every order of four, but perhaps they stopped that, and that would be responsible for the discrepency. So far as quality, I am not one of the experts, but I can say that it fit perfectly the first time, that the web site is especially easy to use, that they are extremely responsive (within minutes to hours to any email), and they are flexible: I asked for a special pocket with special measurements and they obliged at no extra charge. The fabric was luxurious but not special like the heavy cottons of my Barbas or similar Giam Paulos, which is not to say you couldn't get such a fabric if you selected it. And the 3 week order time they promise was exact to the day. If you have time and you can fenagle swatches out of Ricky at Jantzen, he is better because he is cheap cheap cheap. But for stress-free effortless ordering, Liste Rouge has everyone beat. Chang has been well-reviewed numerous times on this site and AAAC, but at least from the standpoint of its website, there is no comparison, I had no idea what I was ordering or what many of the terms meant and it was very inflexible. Chang is also very ominous with its guarantees, where as Liste Rouge promises to make the first shirt over and over again until it is right.