I really like the fit in iammatt's photograph. I would prefer a wider shoulder though. But I understand that this is the Neapolitan style.
mafoofan's fit is nice too, but I can't help but think it could stand to be a little smaller in overall dimensions. While iammatt's shirt shows of his flat abdomen, mafoofan's shirt seems to make him look frumpy (when he clearly isn't). I am sure these shirts look better in real life though. Pictures tend to emphasise imperfections.
Still think the front of iammatt's shirt would look better pattern-matched, but we've already argued that one to death.