I've actually only tried the vintage parfum (I've bought it for a quite cheap price when StC went first online and their prices were messed up), which is marvelous. I'd wait for rach's opinion, he's the master of Jicky in this thread. IIRC, EdP is preferrable to EdT, but quite inferior to the parfum (which is much more expensive, so I suppose 50 USD for 1.7 oz EdP is very well worth it). But maybe it was the other way around and EdT is preferrable to EdP? I remember rach saying something about different formulas.