On the whole, I'm not a big fan of the MFK lineup. It's hard to describe, but I find so many of their scents feel very matte and earthy, even the ones without notes that one typically describes as earthy. Lumiere Noire is like that too. It starts out very promising: it's an earthy, dirty rose, featuring patchouli and cumin. But as it dries down, it becomes quite flat and lifeless; it feels more like a powder than a perfume.
For the sake of fairness, though, I should add that I haven't seen others online describing the MFK lineup that way, so it may very well just be a quirk of mine. Lots of people online have a very high opinion of Lumiere Noire in particular.
If you're interested in the earthy, dirty rose category generally, there's lots and lots of stuff I'd recommend, including George Sand by MPG.
Amber Oud for me today. (By Kilian)