or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Streetwear and Denim › Are brick & mortar menswear stores still viable businesses?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Are brick & mortar menswear stores still viable businesses?

post #1 of 20
Thread Starter 
I've long toyed with the idea of opening a brick-and-mortar menswear store in my neighborhood, which is gentrifying, evolving, diverse, and also underserved. I know that I can buy the right merchandise to meet the neighborhood's needs, maintain an inviting atmosphere that welcomes customers, think strategically to leverage the storefront and the name on the sign for auxiliary business ventures, and run the business intelligently. PR is simple; there are a thousand menswear blogs that will cover your launch.

But we're in the age of online retail, where East Dane can undercut your price by 25% in a minute's notice and Revolve offers coupon codes that their sales volume affords. I could obviously sell my wares online as well as B&M (e-commerce setups have become dead-ass simple), but I'd be a drop in a large pond. I can style products and take gorgeous photos so that consumers aren’t looking at t-shirts on mannequins (as Fok said, TOJ’s biggest strength is their product styling), but I've been a StyleForum member for long enough to know that informed consumers know their product and first and foremost shop on price.

I’d like to get StyleForum’s take on the state of retail menswear boutiques. Here are a few thought-starters:

  • your personal experience with the market (maybe we can hear from some of the proprietors on the forum?)
  • reasons to enter or avoid the market
  • gaps in the overall market that are worth exploring/exploiting
  • examples of young stores doing it right (don’t say American Rag or another store that’s been around for decades)

Thanks. I look forward to the discussion.
post #2 of 20

AFAIK, save yourself the trouble, it's an uphill battle all the way.  Largely, it's going to cost you way more money (way more) than you think to start it, that is assuming you can get "SF brands" to even consider supplying to you.  

post #3 of 20
You considering doing this in NYC?
The rent alone will kill you.

I shop in brick and mortar stores all the time. Probably 98% vs 2% online. I like to physically see/feel/try on items before purchase.

I was looking at a mason's bag(I would use it as an overnight bag) recently and saw that it was on sale online. I actually went to the store to see what it looked like close up and intended to buy it. It was the display model and was a little dusty so I passed and bought online(it was also the last one in the store.) One of the rare instances that I went online vs in store.

Clothing....I actually can't remember the last time that I bought online. I mean...it helps that I live in NYC where just about everything is a subway ride away.

I think there is definitely a place for them..but doing it in NYC is very expensive.
post #4 of 20
Thread Starter 
Quote:
assuming you can get "SF brands" to even consider supplying to you.

I've thought about this as well. Does anyone have experience with manufacturers who won't sell to certain retailers?
Quote:
Originally Posted by ter1413 View Post

You considering doing this in NYC?
The rent alone will kill you.

I shop in brick and mortar stores all the time. Probably 98% vs 2% online. I like to physically see/feel/try on items before purchase.

I was looking at a mason's bag(I would use it as an overnight bag) recently and saw that it was on sale online. I actually went to the store to see what it looked like close up and intended to buy it. It was the display model and was a little dusty so I passed and bought online(it was also the last one in the store.) One of the rare instances that I went online vs in store.

Clothing....I actually can't remember the last time that I bought online. I mean...it helps that I live in NYC where just about everything is a subway ride away.

I think there is definitely a place for them..but doing it in NYC is very expensive.

Is $4K/mo too high?
post #5 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by blank View Post

I've thought about this as well. Does anyone have experience with manufacturers who won't sell to certain retailers?
Is $4K/mo too high?

You mean for rent? In nYc? Too LOW!
post #6 of 20
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by ter1413 View Post

You mean for rent? In nYc? Too LOW!

Well, that's what I can get in Brooklyn.
post #7 of 20
If you're trying to open a retail store and are worried about the rent cost you should not be opening a retail store.
post #8 of 20
We've been primarily brick and mortar for the greater amount of our life at PDG. even now with an online shop 95% of our business is done in house or over the phone.

I can elaborate on what I think it takes to run a successful physical shop but I can also boil it down to a few key questions;

"where are you?"
"who are youre neighbors and what are they doing?"
"what unique service do you provide to this neighborhood?"

NYC is a daunting market mainly because of these questions - there are a hundred places to shop and you have to stand out. Portland, on the other hand has only a handful (though the market is growing and new friends and competition are sprouting up!) so we're able to bring something special to the table.
post #9 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by blank View Post

Well, that's what I can get in Brooklyn.

Ok. What part of Brooklyn?
post #10 of 20

"examples of young stores doing it right (don’t say American Rag or another store that’s been around for decades)"

 

The first vendor that came to my mind is EP.  I think they're staying away from carrying other brands and focusing more on their EP brand (which is probably a lot higher margin) - walts, driggs, shoes etc...

 

They focus on creating similar or better quality products at below respective designer price points - their in-house pants are the perfect example. 

post #11 of 20

Hey blank. Longtime SF lurker... never really felt the desire to post though until this.

 

Your situation is a bit different, being in NYC. I live in Seattle and would love it if there were a couple more brick & mortar menswear stores here (the only non-online one is Jack Straw). The prices are indeed usually a bit higher than online (partially because of WA's sizable sales tax), but I shop at Jack Straw a lot because I like the owners and enjoy buying from a local shop. Without them, I wouldn't be able to try on EG (and other brands') pieces before buying, so I'm willing to pay a bit extra on a few pieces every season in order to support them.

 

If you want to do it and you think you can make it work - do it. New York is competitive, but if you provide something different than the other shops there, you could make it work. (Don't open a shop if all you're creating is another version of a shop that already exists). By the way, 4k rent sounds insanely cheap.

 

re: market gaps, maybe not applicable to NYC, but in Seattle the buys of summer items are always minimal because of the weather here (never many shorts or short sleeve BDs). Same thing with shoes... there are no places to buy the shoe brands I like (what I wouldn't give for a local Tricker's, Viberg, or Visvim stockist). If you're thinking about opening a shop, I'm sure it's because there isn't already a store in your area that's exactly the way you'd like it to be. So, make it exist.

post #12 of 20

@SirMeowly  What about Blue Owl in seattle?

post #13 of 20
Plant your store in DC! Tons of young dudes with $$$, but the retail scene blows.
post #14 of 20

.

post #15 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by MooseRooster View Post
 

@Distorbiant never been there... or even knew it existed. Thanks for the info. Just took a look at them online and it seems nice enough, but they don't really sell the brands I'm into right now. We also have Totokaelo here, which is nice, but their inventory in-store is the exact same as online. A store called Blackbird that was great also used to exist, but closed about a year ago.

 

Understandable. Blue Owl is very well known in the online raw denim community. 

 

It was a shame that blackbird closed down. I always had great customer service experiences with them.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Streetwear and Denim
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Streetwear and Denim › Are brick & mortar menswear stores still viable businesses?