time to bring this thread back from the dead.
i just received 2 casual button-ups from hickeystyle that i was able to obtain for $53 each, and here are my first impressions:
1) I ordered a medium, since the medium in J crew are slightly big on me from the chest down, but perfect on the shoulders. I figured since they are cut slim, a medium would work. Well, I am surprised how nicely they fit me on the shoulders and the chest down, but if I lost any more weight, I would prolly have to get these tailored.
2) The neck on these shirts is huge, i am not sure why it was designed this way. I have a 15.5 neck, and these are quiet big on me. I don't plan on wearing a tie, so it doesnt make a huge difference, but just an observation.
3) The fabric is really nice and thick, some of the nice fabrics i have seen on casual shirts.