Re: Vanishing Elephant sizing - I'll add to the confusion and say that I went with a 12 in the oxfords I bought. I'm usually a 12 in sneakers, but sometimes find dress shoes to be a touch big, so I often size a half size down. An 11 in the oxfords I bought would have been too small.
Yeah, unfortunately they don't come in half sizes. I'm gonna sleep on it.