or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Noodles' Good Natured Advice Thread
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Noodles' Good Natured Advice Thread - Page 303

post #4531 of 11987
Quote:
Originally Posted by sugarbutch View Post

Why do you think the 40 is too big? Judging by the pictures above, it looks much more workable than the 38.

I agree. Rudals, I think you would be pleasantly surprised at how good that suit would look after Fields put his touch on it.

Styles mentioned in this thread:

post #4532 of 11987

That's quite interesting. The 38R looks better to my eyes. The 40R just looks really baggy.

post #4533 of 11987
^ Just remember, it's easier to fix too big than too small. Of course if it doesn't fit in the shoulders, don't buy the thing.
post #4534 of 11987
It fits better in the chest and shoulders...most important areas. You just have to see the potential it has if a good tailor gets their hands on it. I would take the 40 over the 38 and you've probably seen that I don't wear sacks for suits.
post #4535 of 11987

you guys do realize that I had no intention of buying. I was only at the mall because wife wanted to buy her pretty little shoes with freaking flowers all over it. BUT, it good to post pix and get feedbacks. I certainly appreciate it all. I guess I will learn a thing or to while just having fun. 

post #4536 of 11987
Quote:
Originally Posted by Claghorn View Post

Larger checks probably work best with an all solid fit.

On the linen tie from HC. I think the only way to wear that pattern effectively is with a double breasted, blue, brown or cotton linen/cotton. It's too strong on its own in a single breasted, bordering on garish (sorry Henry). But just peeking out from a DB, I think it might be quite nice.

De sense... Want to test my theory? wink.gif
post #4537 of 11987
Quote:
Originally Posted by jungleroller View Post


So far I'm thinking the following options: 3 roll 2, Soft shoulder, Notch Lapel/Wide lapel, Patch Pockets/patch chest pocket, Double vent, 4 functioning buttons, Half lined, no ticket pocket,

Some things I'm unsure about or leaning towards: No pick stitching,

If this appointment doesn't work out I'll still need a couple SC's so I may end up going back to the bay or Kulata has given me some links on Yoox to check out as well.

 

 

sounds good jr.   IMO the patch chest pocket isn't a great option.  Two probs-

 

1.  They don't take a square well.  Because it's a casual jacket you're going to go puffed silk, and most squares (Kent Wang's  an exception because they're 13 by 13) )  won't sit in there without unsightly bulging.

2.  Square in, it looks like you have a flower pot pasted to your chest.    That's a Foo observation, but once u see it u can't forget it.  

post #4538 of 11987
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pliny View Post


sounds good jr.   IMO the patch chest pocket isn't a great option.  Two probs-

1.  They don't take a square well.  Because it's a casual jacket you're going to go puffed silk, and most squares (Kent Wang's  an exception because they're 13 by 13) )  won't sit in there without unsightly bulging.
2.  Square in, it looks like you have a flower pot pasted to your chest.    That's a Foo observation, but once u see it u can't forget it.  

Good Call! Thank you!

I was at Nordstrom rack trying on Jackets 42 and 44's. I was having the shoulder issues that Rudals had. Is this due to the shoulders are too wide on the jackets or not wide enough? It was happening in both sizes. I couldn't go any smaller the 42's were cut very slim. Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)

post #4539 of 11987
Quote:
Originally Posted by jungleroller View Post

Good Call! Thank you!

I was at Nordstrom rack trying on Jackets 42 and 44's. I was having the shoulder issues that Rudals had. Is this due to the shoulders are too wide on the jackets or not wide enough? It was happening in both sizes. I couldn't go any smaller the 42's were cut very slim. Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)


If I understood jefferyd on this topic, shoulder width as being the issue is a common misconception. Rather this is often caused by tightness through the shoulder blades pulling at the sleeve fabric to cause the divots, i.e. Not enough fabric in the upper back.

If pictures from behind don't identify this as the issue, then the problem is often related to sleeve shape or how the sleeve is attached to the sleeve head. Due to my forward shoulders, Despos recommended that I have the sleeves on my jackets recut and reattached at the sleeve head to pretty much eliminate the issue. Given the expense relative to the jacket price I just chose to let them go.

If I understand this issue correctly from inquiring in the tailor thread the divot issue actually has little to do with shoulder width. YMMV.
post #4540 of 11987

JR:  what jackets were you trying on?  My experience with the Rack in Chicago is that, apart from the occasional Canali or Samuelsohn, it is largely filled with Hickey Freeman's diffusion line and cheap fashion suits.  I recall the fit on the HF diffusion line suits as being pretty wonky.

post #4541 of 11987
Calven Klein, Tommy Hilfiger, Hugo Boss and Nordstrom brand. None of which I was crazy about just based on names but I wanted to give them a whirl. This was the Rack out in Orland Park btw.
post #4542 of 11987
Quote:
Originally Posted by jungleroller View Post

Calven Klein, Tommy Hilfiger, Hugo Boss and Nordstrom brand. None of which I was crazy about just based on names but I wanted to give them a whirl. This was the Rack out in Orland Park btw.

Those are all crap.  The only jackets I've ever bought from the Rack were Samuelsohn or John W. Nordstrom, Signature Collection (not regular JWN, which is crap, but a special line made by Southwick).  Otherwise, you're much better off geting sportcoats off of EBay or going the MTM route you are trying.

post #4543 of 11987
Quote:
Originally Posted by luv2breformed View Post


If I understood jefferyd on this topic, shoulder width as being the issue is a common misconception. Rather this is often caused by tightness through the shoulder blades pulling at the sleeve fabric to cause the divots, i.e. Not enough fabric in the upper back.

If pictures from behind don't identify this as the issue, then the problem is often related to sleeve shape or how the sleeve is attached to the sleeve head. Due to my forward shoulders, Despos recommended that I have the sleeves on my jackets recut and reattached at the sleeve head to pretty much eliminate the issue. Given the expense relative to the jacket price I just chose to let them go.

If I understand this issue correctly from inquiring in the tailor thread the divot issue actually has little to do with shoulder width. YMMV.

 

This @jungleroller.

 

I don't remeber where I saw the image of that, it was very descriptive but it's simple, I will try to explain myself. The space where the sleeve goes forms an oval. The sleeve is cut the same way. So when you have large shoulder blades that oval - formed by the back part and chest area - turns into a circle. The sleeve expands to fit that circle and that forms those divots. That is what I remember.

post #4544 of 11987
While wife shopped...
RLBL, RLPL then all Zegnas. All 40 R





post #4545 of 11987
Noodles, you are apparently not a 40R in those brands. All have bowed lapels on you. The 40R in the HF wasn't a great cut, but at least the lapels fell cleanly. Next time you're out shopping, look for that bowing, and if you see it, size up. Don't worry about what the label says.

(And we knew you weren't intending to buy the jackets shown.)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear

Styles mentioned in this thread:

Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Noodles' Good Natured Advice Thread