or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Good Natured Advice Thread (improving a business wardrobe)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Good Natured Advice Thread (improving a business wardrobe) - Page 2332

post #34966 of 37395

Formosa's already have considerable structure in the shoulder...especially compared to many of their Neapolitan competitors. 

 

My prediction:

 

This will be futile...Noodles will ruin a couple grand worth of perfectly acceptable jackets...and probably implode.

post #34967 of 37395
Quote:
Originally Posted by PCK1 View Post
 

Formosa's already have considerable structure in the shoulder...especially compared to many of their Neapolitan competitors. 

 

My prediction:

 

This will be futile...Noodles will ruin a couple grand worth of perfectly acceptable jackets...and probably implode.

So pessimistic. You think Field will start on this stupid idea if he thought it was not going to work out? 

 

Maybe I'll shove some tissues underneath my shoulders.

post #34968 of 37395
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Noodles View Post
 

I would be looking at losing at least $500 per suit. 

Whatever I have said, they're good suits with good fabric. It's just that I have narrow shoulders 

While you may not LOVE the lack of structure (a subjective notion, it seems), I'd be hard pressed to find someone who thinks your Formosa's look bad on you, or that they (presumably, due to shoulders bit) make you look wimpy.

 

I didn't say you SHOULD sell them, only that selling them would net you something for them, rather than embarking on a trek that is almost certain to end in failure...while taking additional funds out of your pocket at the same time.

 

Depending on where you live and the quality of the tailor, I'd venture a guess that you're looking at at least $100-200 per jacket to even try to have this done...

post #34969 of 37395
Quote:
Originally Posted by ericgereghty View Post

I'd be hard pressed to find someone who thinks your Formosa's look bad on you, or that they (presumably, due to shoulders bit) make you look wimpy.

But DressedWell says anyone wearing a Formosa looks bad, and they're the authority on good fashion.
post #34970 of 37395
Quote:
Originally Posted by venividivicibj View Post


But DressedWell says anyone wearing a Formosa looks bad, and they're the authority on good fashion.

I'll be totally honest, I have NO idea what that is, or who you're referencing lol.

post #34971 of 37395
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Noodles View Post

 

You think Field will start on this stupid idea if he thought it was not going to work out? 

 

 

 

Field is a business just like any other.

 

And I guarantee if you walk in there and tell them you want to add padding to the shoulders that they will take your money and do the work...even if it doesn't end up the way you think it will. It will be your idea that is flawed...not their work. 

 

They fit fine. Just suck it up...or throw them all out and buy new ones. 

post #34972 of 37395
Quote:
Originally Posted by PCK1 View Post

Field is a business just like any other.

And I guarantee if you walk in there and tell them you want to add padding to the shoulders that they will take your money and do the work...even if it doesn't end up the way you think it will. It will be your idea that is flawed...not their work. 

They fit fine. Just suck it up...or throw them all out and buy new ones. 
Not necessarily true - Field once told me rather bluntly that the issue I wanted to fix on a jacket was too risky and therefore not worth it. He's an honest and upfront chap.
post #34973 of 37395
Quote:
Originally Posted by lordsuperb View Post

How so?

If you want a suit with more structure / shoulder padding, you should buy a suit with more structure / shoulder padding. You don't take a suit that's designed to be pretty much the exact opposite of that and pay a tailor to morph it into something else. Best case is you end up with a mutant hybrid that's neither here nor there, not to mention pretty much impossible to resell. Worst case something goes wrong and you end up with something you like even less. He's better off enjoying these suits and acquiring suits that are cut more to his liking going forward or selling these suits to raise cash for their replacements.

Don't buy Rubi and try to make it Huntsman or vice versa. It's a disaster waiting to happen in most cases.
post #34974 of 37395
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Noodles View Post

I would be looking at losing at least $500 per suit. 
Whatever I have said, they're good suits with good fabric. It's just that I have narrow shoulders 

That's throwing good money away. For $1,500, you could get two SuitSupply suits and have a larger wardrobe. I can see how you might want something with a bit more extension and padding in the shoulders (NB: shoulder extension, which compensates for narrow shoulders when done properly, and shoulder padding, which does add structure but tends to compensate more for sloping shoulders, are different). Adding shoulder padding will give you a more structured look, but it won't extend the shoulders.

I still think you are better off accepting the suits you have as is. As I said, the cost of doing this work is going to set you back two SuitSupply suits. It also is not going to be the same as getting suits that are cut in the most flattering possible way for you. I think your current Formosas look fine on you; I can see how a bit more structure and extension in the shoulders might flatter you more and this is good to know going forward, but use this knowledge for future purchases. $1,500 is way too much to spend for this surgical experiment.
post #34975 of 37395
Quote:
Originally Posted by archibaldleach View Post

That's throwing good money away. For $1,500, you could get two SuitSupply suits and have a larger wardrobe. I can see how you might want something with a bit more extension and padding in the shoulders (NB: shoulder extension, which compensates for narrow shoulders when done properly, and shoulder padding, which does add structure but tends to compensate more for sloping shoulders, are different). Adding shoulder padding will give you a more structured look, but it won't extend the shoulders.

I still think you are better off accepting the suits you have as is. As I said, the cost of doing this work is going to set you back two SuitSupply suits. It also is not going to be the same as getting suits that are cut in the most flattering possible way for you. I think your current Formosas look fine on you; I can see how a bit more structure and extension in the shoulders might flatter you more and this is good to know going forward, but use this knowledge for future purchases. $1,500 is way too much to spend for this surgical experiment.


Don't talk him out of it!!! I want to see where this goes.
post #34976 of 37395
Quote:
Originally Posted by archibaldleach View Post

If you want a suit with more structure / shoulder padding, you should buy a suit with more structure / shoulder padding. You don't take a suit that's designed to be pretty much the exact opposite of that and pay a tailor to morph it into something else. Best case is you end up with a mutant hybrid that's neither here nor there, not to mention pretty much impossible to resell. Worst case something goes wrong and you end up with something you like even less. He's better off enjoying these suits and acquiring suits that are cut more to his liking going forward or selling these suits to raise cash for their replacements.

Don't buy Rubi and try to make it Huntsman or vice versa. It's a disaster waiting to happen in most cases.

You've never met Mr. Field.
post #34977 of 37395
Will Field may be a businessman but he is more passionate about his work. I have dumb ideas and requests being that I am a dumb fart, but he has steered me away from them by explaining why. He just doesn't take your money and F you over like some people.
post #34978 of 37395
Quote:
Originally Posted by lordsuperb View Post

You've never met Mr. Field.

It's not the tailor I doubt; it's the idea and whether it's worth doing.
post #34979 of 37395

You can learn a lot by having a tailor tell you that something is a bad idea.

post #34980 of 37395
FWIW, I recently had a SC altered from fully lined to quarter lined and had the shoulder pads replaced with much thinner pads. Tailor said minimal padding was necessary - couldn't go to unpadded. Removing lining and having to finish seams was the labor intensive part. Total bill was $250, but well worth it. Jacket is a powder blue hopsack and now far more useful, feels lighter and more comfortable in warmer weather. To my mind, the cost was worth it as I now have a jacket I'll wear more. Was purchased a a mtm pre-SF when I didn't know better. From a looks point of view, shoulder has a more roped look.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Good Natured Advice Thread (improving a business wardrobe)