Keep in mind that some Suit Supply salesmen are notorious for trying to get customers to size down. I’m sure it’s not universal, but some of them seem committed to imitating the photographs on their website where the models are often wearing jackets too small for them.
The fellow was very adamant about the size! Tricked me. Good thing SuSu has an excellent return/exchange policy/
So group consensus is the 40R Hudson has the best fit from the 3 above?