I think both gun clubs are not right for Noodles at this point in time. I think he should stick to a high contrast look for now because it works easiest for his complexion. A warm look will take quite a bit more effort.
@Cao Cao, I am on record liking the way those suits look on you, though I also have encouraged you to look at other cuts. I am surprised to see you considering adding more things in that cut to your wardrobe rather than looking at many other options. That said, the pattern is very nice and I think reasonably versatile (though less so than a proper navy blazer).