This has become a Lounge type discussion.
Thanks for the altered pic, Elio. It brings out a lot that Coxsackie has nicely articulated.
Context is interesting: start from the top, covering the entire picture with your hand, and slowly move downward revealing more and more of the shot. If I do that, I like the lower stance much more on the left. Something about showing more tie, having more shirt revealed is pleasing to my eye. Reveal the entire fit and then issues arise with regard to the leg-line (remembering that this is just one picture, perhaps from an angle that exaggerates proportions along one dimension).
I guess there are two things that it would be interesting to see (not that one could do this on photoshop or that you should). (1) Raising the hem on the left keeping button point constant on the body (there are limits to how much this can be done) in the left example and (2) just raising the hem on the right.