Agreed @DonRaphael the one on the right seems more attractive to my eye.
Carmina Rain Last by any chance?
Thanks for your opinions, gentlemen.
@LEVOOSH, to the left is Edward Green, Inverness on the 888 last in Dark Oak and to the right is Carmina on the Rain last in Vegano marron (medium brown). Funny 3/3 suggested keeping the Carminas. Goes to show that beauty doesn't have a price.
As for your question @Caustic Man, the EG pair was purchased used (appr. 5x). Thus, I can return it for a full refund if I wish to. The Carminas I'd have to sell at a loss.
I also have the opportunity to buy a second pair of EGs NIB exactly like those above but in burgundy if I wish (> 50 % off retail), or trade the ones I have for a burgundy pair (paying some extra since the burgundy pair is unused), or choose a full refund for the used ones shown in the picture.