Noodlers, I'm thinking about another pair of shoes. Among my dress rotation, I have:
--black captoe oxfords
--black chelsea boots
--brown brogued wingtips
--dark brown longwing bluchers
--dark brown pebble grain boots
--mid-brown wholecuts in a lightweight calf grain
--bitter chocolate (dark brown) suede double monks
In slightly more casual construction, I've got walnut (light brown) chukkas, dark brown venetian loafers, and some "casual leather" brogued wingtips (AE Neumoks).
What would you do next? I'm tempted by a brogued oxford in some kind of snuff suede, but perhaps also a single monk in brown calf leather. Shoes are a complementary rather than a primary focus of fit construction for me, so I'm happy to be guided by wiser heads.