Allen Edmonds and Jalan Swirijaya are the only brands I've ever owned that didn't make my feet hurt in some way at some point. Meermin takes a lot of breaking in (and still isn't great). I had a pair of Carmina for about a month; best fitting of their lasts for me. But it just was uncomfortable and they were traded. Yount shoes fit alright. C&J fit ok. But they aren't actually comfortable. Just not uncomfortable.
Interesting comment about Jalan Sriwijaya. Are they good? Where did you get them? Strangely enough, though they are made here in Indonesia, they are not sold here. Probably because there is no market for quality footwear