I've seen some good review online from blogs/websites. Not sure if they are somewhat biases - I was wondering if anyone has first hand experience with them and has any thoughts on the suits you got. Thanks!
Although I can't speak to the fit of a Proper Suit suit or tuxedo just yet, I did get fitted for a tuxedo a few weeks ago and although my experience with custom fitted suits is fairly limited, I was impressed. Just as a background, I have many suits from a custom tailor in Knoxville, TN called John H. Daniel. Until moving to ATL, this is where I got most of my suits. My Proper Suit fitting was head and shoulders above that at JHD. I can't begin to tell you how many different measurements were taken, but the gist of the experience revolved around me trying on several different sized jackets and pants and Richard (one of PS co-founders) meticulously taking measurements to determine how my fit compared against those of the jackets and suit pants I was trying on.
When it comes to quality of the fabrics, I don't know enough to make a determination on how they stand up to most of the suit fabrics discussed on SF. However, I eagerly await the delivery of my tuxedo, which should happen in the next couple of weeks. At that time, I'll have another fitting with Richard to make sure everything is correct and if not, the tux will be sent back for alterations.
Assuming things go well, I plan on buying a few suits and a sports jacket in the next couple of months.
Hope that helps..
I'd be wary of them. They offer good fabrics, but the quality and fit seems to be hit and miss. But the oddest thing about them is their utter lack of customer service. They come across more like party boys and this is a sideline that a real business. I have gotten suits and jackets from them that are not quite what I ordered and literally have to track them down through multiple means just to get it addressed and rather than apologizing or offering to make it right, they just shirk it off and say it will be corrected next time. They also promise delivery dates that they do not meet. Lastly, their website is erratic and not very functional as they claim (you are given a dedicated url to check past and upcoming orders but it's never updated.) Overall, I stuck with them for a while because once you have your sizes on file it's pretty convenient and the fabrics (higher end) are nice, but think I have to look elsewhere.