Guys have you looked at Ashland leather? All american made products with leather for horween. The "tony the ant" model wallet looks pretty perfect to me.
I have! The Louis is almost perfect (the Tony is a little more wallet than I'm looking for). If the Louis had two small sides instead of a small/large combo, it would be just what I'm looking for. Someone also recommended the card wallet from Mitchell Leather, which looks very good as well. So I have options (thanks to those who helped me find them). The appeal of Gustin offering something along these lines is, or course, the price advantage of crowd sourcing. I don't expect Gustin to drop everything so they can make me my special wallet request, so I'll probably buy something from Ashland or Mitchell. Thanks to those here who helped me find what I'm looking for!