Originally Posted by rydenfan
Can anyone who owns the shirt comparing sizing to another brand? Like if you wear size X in J Crew and you wear size Y in Gustin.
I wear Large in Gustin shirts and typically find the following size-brand combinations work for me:
- Medium in Gitman Vintage
- Large in WvG Before Dinner and Medium in WvG After Dinner (AD fits better for me)
- Medium in J. Crew (although there is a decent amount of variety over the years, I would say current Mediums at J Crew fit me well or are a bit big, while I have found ones from a few years ago to be a bit more loose)
- Medium in RRL (although there is a lot of variance here, as medium flannels and chambrays tend to fit me but be a bit loose and long, while some other random RRL button ups have required me to size up to an L)
I would say that I have found Large in Gustin to be closest in fit to the normal Medium in Gitman Vintage (every so often they have some shirts that fit radically different). However, what works for each person is driven heavily by body type. I am a pretty average american (i.e., I could stand to lose a few pounds), so I cannot go as slim or tailored as I would prefer or as a lot of people on this site would do. E.g., if I was a bit slimmer, I could probably size down in a few of the brands above, so depending on your body type, you may not experience the same sizing equivalency.