I really like the colors, patterns, and collars on HF shirts. Not too keen on the fit and construction, but if they fit you, I think they can be a great value. They turn up at Filene's Basement on deep discount all the time.
I picked up an older HF shirt that was just a balloon on me. The shoulder width was huge. I really liked the shirt fabric, but ended up selling it. Perhaps the newer ones have a better cut.
I'll soon see and let everyone know. I bought a HF shirt from the store in San Francisco last month and it fits pretty well, I might take it to my tailor for a little tweaking. I really like the colors and fabrics of the 4-pack I got from Bluefly, but as Chorse123 mentioned, the construction isn't the very best. I opened one last night and upon closer inspection, there are lots of loose threads around the buttonholes, I had to do some judicious snipping with a razor to trim them off. Otherwise, it seems pretty sturdy, especially around the shoulders and body seams.
I'm going to wash the first one a few times to see if there's much shrinkage. The collar is about 1/8" too big, but if it snugs up just a bit, it should fit fine. In any case, I'll post some pics in the next few days once it's been through a few washes.
Some Harvie & Hudson shirts I recieved a few weeks ago. I I like the fabrics but am not too impressed by the collar/cuffs or the fit (didn't expect them to be slim-fit of course, but the fit on these was very generous).