or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › The Watch Appreciation Thread
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

The Watch Appreciation Thread - Page 845

post #12661 of 34963
Quote:
Originally Posted by johnvw View Post


Please delete. (Double post).
post #12662 of 34963
Quote:
Originally Posted by PartagasIV View Post

You're much better off with a pen than wasting your money on a Montblanc watch.

 

Well that is certainly an ignorant thing to say...

 

ml_image.1060446.jpg

post #12663 of 34963
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hampton View Post

Really? Wow did not know this at all. 

Now you know wink.gif

I would place mont blanc around omega, maybe a little overpriced, but if you can get a deal I would get one.
post #12664 of 34963
Quote:
Originally Posted by EMartNJ View Post

Well that is certainly an ignorant thing to say...

LL

truth. montblanc has come a long way in their watchmaking. they are making some really great pieces these days. not just nice to look at, solid and finely crafted and decorated movements too.
post #12665 of 34963
Quote:
Originally Posted by in stitches View Post

truth. montblanc has come a long way in their watchmaking. they are making some really great pieces these days. not just nice to look at, solid and finely crafted and decorated movements too.


I love that Rieussec and it is a great price (for that style) at around $10k. The only thing that would prevent me from buying it, money notwithstanding, is that its really big.

post #12666 of 34963
Quote:
Originally Posted by Find Finn View Post


Now you know wink.gif
I would place mont blanc around omega, maybe a little overpriced, but if you can get a deal I would get one.

Thanks mate! I have one at work selling his MontBlanc for $5k he bought it for $12k. I'm getting a pretty good deal could even sell it for more. I don't like gold but this one I could use...

 

This is the one:

MontBlanc Star 102345

movadobaby_2220_1685448895.gif

post #12667 of 34963
Spoke too soon, I was under the impression they were still mostly ETA or modified ETA movements. shog[1].gif
post #12668 of 34963
i find it really superficial to judge a watch based on whether it is a eta movement or inhouse. you know what youre getting with a eta movement, a movement that is widely used and is relatively reliable since it is produced by swatch, this means that can be easily repaired and proven functional. inhouse for the less famous brands is more dubious imo.
post #12669 of 34963
Quote:
Originally Posted by PartagasIV View Post

Spoke too soon, I was under the impression they were still mostly ETA or modified ETA movements. shog[1].gif

I believe ETA bought Valjoux.
post #12670 of 34963
Mont Blanc also produces watches with movements made by Minerva,biggrin.gif
post #12671 of 34963
dont forget, sometimes purchased movements from large movement houses are:

a.) exclusive to a certain order and very high end indeed

b.) highly altered/upgraded by the buyer

just because a movement comes from a supplier, doesnt necessarily mean it is lower end/bulk rate so to speak.
post #12672 of 34963

Hmmm... would you buy a Patek Philippe pen? Or would you buy a Louis Vuitton engagement ring? I would rather purchase a PP watch than a pen and I would rather have a MontBlanc pen than a PP pen. As for an engagement ring, I would rather buy a Tiffany's engagement ring than an LV ring (if one even exists.) My point is... a name means a lot to me. It tells me about the heritage and craftsmanship. It sort of adds a characteristic/soul to the object and it makes the watch more than just a timepiece. Some people could care less and just buy the pretty piece with a decent or very good movement, but I want that soul! I want to feel passionate and proud about my watch. I would definitely skip the MontBlanc and consider a different timepiece. I'm not saying that MB is lacking a respectable name, because they really aren't! Their name is respectable in the profession that made them renown around the world and that's writing instruments. That's just my opinion.

post #12673 of 34963
1. paragraph breaks are your friend.

2. buying an engagement ring from tiffany is asking to be raped. a diamond is diamond, no craftsmanship involved. go buy the same stone from your local jeweler for 1/3 the price, or spend the money on a larger/nicer stone.

3. i would gladly buy patek pens if they made them, and i liked them. they make some really cool cufflinks id buy in a instant if i had the dough.

4. you really should read up on MB, they are not just a fashion brand pumping out watches. its not a patek, or a lange or AP or VC, but they have garnered the know how, and the means, and make some great watches. to discount that for name, is a mistake imo.

in the end, buy what makes you happy, but make an informed decision, not a purely emotional one that could likely regret down the road.
post #12674 of 34963

I don't think you can get a diamond with the same grading as a Tiffany's diamond for 1/3 of the cost. A diamond isn't just a diamond, there's a grading system for quality. If you get a diamond with the same grading as Tiff's from a no-name brand, you would save money, but not at 1/3 of the cost. Plus you get free cleaning, polishing, and great service for the rest of your life for free with Tiffany's.

 

I never said that MontBlanc is just a fashion brand. I'm not saying that they're like Burberry or Gucci's watch department. If anything, MontBlanc is like Louis Vuitton's watch depart. Very well made watches, but still, it's Louis Vuitton. Regardless of a caliber movement... it's Louis Vuitton.

 

Would you rather buy a Grand Seiko over a Rolex Milgauss? I know their movement embarrasses a Rolex movement (because it's Seiko and it's better), but I'd still choose the Rolex.

 

I guess... to each his own. Right?

post #12675 of 34963

A friend who is in the jewelry business has a MB watch.  I think he likes the esthetic more than the movement, but as was previously stated, the movement's not bad.  Certainly not in the class of Patek or Dufour or Voutilainen, etc, but few are esp at that price.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › The Watch Appreciation Thread