Seiko Superior - has a nice heft and that date window reminds me of the VC Overseas. Even has a display caseback!
Seagull M17 - strap is pretty crap and will have to be replaced, but dial is decent and pretty elegant.
His watches have never been my taste, but no watch can be everything to everyone. However, that one does go nicely with your shirt. Hope you enjoy and wear it in good health!
FMs never seemed to catch on in my region. Where I live the few ADs were heavily discounting them, still couldn't move them and they would eventually drop the line and sell them at clearance prices.
As for compliments from women, at least in my experience women tend to love Muller and Cartier. Even if there are other brand that are more elite, and have finer finishes, they like FM and Cartier. One of the former FM ADs used to sell mostly the women's models, or on occasion they would sell a men's model when a wife came in to buy the husband a watch and it wasn't going to be a Rolex.