I took a stroll down Madison and Fifth so that you guys can't say I don't ever take advice:
The 504 is just thrown in for reference. It is not actually under consideration. Though it is physically smaller than the 372, it looks bigger on the wrist to me, since it is all dial. The overall chunkiness of the 372 makes the bigness more expected and thus more okay, at least to me. Verdict? Yes, it is a big ass watch--so what!