Originally Posted by Neo_Version 7
To be fair, he is.
Originally Posted by archibaldleach
And he still would be. Tied for most SB wins, record for most SB starts, record for conference championship starts, record for most playoff wins, etc. Peyton can have his regular season stats. I'll take the rings over the stats any day.
"Who is the GOAT?" is an inherently unanswerable question in any sport, no more so than football, which relies on the performance of more than twenty players to achieve a goal. If you put the most credence in championship wins, you like Brady, Montana, or Bradshaw. If you like statistics, it's Manning or Favre. No QB has ever had a better overall skill set than Elway, and no one has ever played the position more proficiently than Rodgers. It's enough of an honor to be in the conversation, which both Brady and Manning are.