Gus, did you ever receive the jacket from Joe? And how spread is your collar (less than 120 degrees)? Trying to find something less spread but where the points will go under the jacket still.
I've had 5 shirts made, and am happy with them fit wise. The fabrics are generally good, even the cheaper fabrics I have chosen (2 ply or executive). Last thanksgiving they had a sale on some higher end fabrics for $75 a shirt.
They are pretty flexible about collars if you talk with them. Joe had one designed for me based on pictures I sent him (I've only ever interacted with him via email).
I have had one pair of trousers, and it came out pretty well. Rishi measured me for the trousers, and hit just about everything dead on. Good strong lines with just enough taper and rise. None of that bunching below the seat. The question is whether they can make fine adjustments to the trousers, something slightly more sculpted near the seat-thigh area. However, trousers are expensive for my budget. There were some $200 VBC fabrics for a while, but they have all disappeared. I can't find anything sub 250 on their website anymore, for trousers. Most fabrics seem to be north of $300, at least on the website.
If anyone has had them reproduce the old brooks collar or even the kamakura collar, do let me know. It would be great just to ask them to reproduce that.