I had same the same dilemma but ultimately went with the cinnamon boot. I actually had the opportunity to try the Haven boots as well. As nice as the copper Haven boots are, I'm hoping the cinnamon last will just give more of that special wow factor. Maybe I'm just talking out of my ass. Either way both boots are really nice.
As a side note on sizing, I found the tts has a little more wiggle room than 1/2 size down. 1/2 down is snug but may stretch out to fit like a glove. I guess which ever way people prefer to wear their boots will ultimately decide which size to get.