or Connect
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Need help matching shoes, belt and pocket square
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Need help matching shoes, belt and pocket square

post #1 of 40
Thread Starter 
Dressing up for sisters wedding. People haven't seen me in about a year and a half and I want to look extra sharp.
I'm 24 light skin blond hair and very slim.

So I need to choose a belt, shoes and a pocket square to go with a dark charcoal gray sports coat, white dress slacks, and a light gray dress shirt (no tie).

I don't know how comfortable I would feel with brown shoes, but I'm not dismissing the Idea completely. I was thinking gray shoes but im mot sure it would work (does that mean I need a gray belt?). Something like this -

Regarding the pocket square I have no idea but I think I need something to pop the whole thing up a bit.

UPDATE - Here is a picture of what I’m aiming for – the guy in the middle.

Edited by Logen - 7/26/13 at 6:45pm
post #2 of 40
Thread Starter 
Anyone?
post #3 of 40

Unless money is no object, the purchase of a pair of grey shoes doesn't seem like the best investment -- grey is certainly less versatile than brown.

post #4 of 40
Brown or black shoes would be a far better choice than grey shoes. Black shoes are better for evening weddings (you don't say what time this is), but brown shoes look better with white or off white trousers. Medium brown / chestnut would probably be perfect assuming this is a summer wedding. Black shoes call for a black belt; brown shoes call for a brown belt in a reasonably similar color.

To be blunt, white trousers, a light grey shirt and charcoal sport coat does not sound like a promising start to an outfit. The light grey shirt sounds the worst, followed by the charcoal sport coat. White or cream trousers can be a good look during the summer, but to put it with a grey "dress" shirt (most of which look awful) and a sport coat that if anything is wintery is not a good plan. It's summer; wear some color (try pale blue, pink or lilac). And put on a tie unless you've been told the wedding is ultra-casual. For that matter, check with your sister to be sure guests aren't showing up in suits (maybe you have, but I have to mention it since a lot of people don't).

I wouldn't bother with a pocket square sans tie, but if you must do a pocket square, stick to plain white linen.
post #5 of 40
no offense, but your whole outfit sounds like a train wreck. it's probably why you're not getting much response. someone will tell you to go get light grey summer trousers, a navy sportcoat, white shirt, black shoes and belt, white pocket square. If they all fit well you will look outstanding.

If this goes as typical on here, you will have reasons why you want to go with what you want, you'll discount the advice, and just buy what you want.

Which is fine, but you won't look great by SF standards. Whether or not you like those standards is up to you.

Are the pants really white?
post #6 of 40
Thread Starter 
Ok so just to answer a few things that came up here.
Yes the pants are really really white. The jacket is very dark, in some lighting you will almost confuse it with black. As for the shirt it's a light gray Calvin Klein.

And probably the most important part, no one is going to be wearing a suit. I think most people will just be with a dress shirt and slacks, maybe a few with a tie. The wedding is at night. So I do think I will stand out.

Why is this such a horrible combination?
post #7 of 40
Quote:
Originally Posted by Douglas View Post

If this goes as typical on here, you will have reasons why you want to go with what you want, you'll discount the advice, and just buy what you want.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Logen View Post

And probably the most important part, no one is going to be wearing a suit. I think most people will just be with a dress shirt and slacks, maybe a few with a tie. The wedding is at night. So I do think I will stand out.

Why is this such a horrible combination?

bigstar[1].gif
post #8 of 40
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Douglas View Post


bigstar[1].gif

So you are basically saying that white pants will not go with a very dark jacket?
What can I do to "save" the outfit? I like the jacket, so what color shirt and slacks should I wear (I don't want it to be a suit)
post #9 of 40
Quote:
Originally Posted by Logen View Post

And probably the most important part, no one is going to be wearing a suit. I think most people will just be with a dress shirt and slacks, maybe a few with a tie. The wedding is at night. So I do think I will stand out.

Yes... you will stand out. As the guy who overdresses for the occasion. If nobody wears a suit, you are going a big statement then and there. Consider it's about the bride and the groom, not about you. 

 

If you want to dress sharp: good Chino/jeans, shirt and tie. Black shoes. You will be among the most elegantly dressed, yet you will not stand out with such a bold statement.

post #10 of 40
Wear the outfit you want. But with black shoes and a black belt. Since everything will be black white or grey, wear any colour pocket square you like. Lilac was a good suggestion.
post #11 of 40
You won't be overdressed. It's your sister's wedding! You should have a jacket on at the very least! A black knit tie would also be in order and would look great.
post #12 of 40
Please don't match non-black belt to non-black shoes, ever. Not the same shade of brown. Not the same kind of material. Not by the same makers.
post #13 of 40
I'm not trying to be a jerk here, so please try to take this at face value.

You sound like someone who is trying to emulate what you see "stars" wear on TV. People like musicians, athletes, actors at awards shows. If that's how you want to dress, more power to you, but you are not going to find much to support you here on this site. The zeitgeist of this site and its membership tends towards a more classical style of dress. Don't confuse that with formality or an overreliance on suits - sportcoats and trousers are well-loved here, but in more conservative, classical, less fashion-oriented modes.

That's not to say there aren't trends on here. That's not to say there isn't some form of groupthink. And even then, no one opinion encapsulates the forum. But there is general agreement on some concepts. I think that, in general, grey shirts, grey shoes, and grey belts are probably relatively unanimously unloved. Spend some time in the "what are you wearing today" thread to see the sorts of outfits that are loved on here. Maybe you'll look at them and think "what a bunch of bores these guys are." Which is your prerogative to think, of course, but then you should also realize that these guys aren't going to be your best source of help given the style you seem to want to pursue. Or perhaps you'll think "hm, that is different than what I have conceived of as good dress, but there's something to it. Let me stick around for a while." And you'll slowly learn, as most of us have. There are some really fantastic dressers on here and most of us slowly learned, or are still learning, how to do what they do. Or maybe you'll love it from the start, who knows.

SF is about good tailoring, great quality, wearing things that fit, and classic, relatively timeless combinations over flashiness and trends. It's almost decidedly not about peacocking with bright colors or dramatic elements. It's about standing out by having something almost sublimely classic, standing out by not standing out.

That may not be for you. You have to decide.

Specific criticisms of what you've proposed:

Charcoal as a sportcoat is difficult. Is it solid, or patterned? Weight? Material? Sheen? Your most basic classic sportcoat will always be the navy blazer, and as you start out wanting nice clothes, you'll find it's the ultimate piece of clothing. When you start, you'll make a lot of mistakes trying to get something amazing that will blow the ladies away, but over time, as you mature with this hobby, should you choose to accept it, you'll realize simple navy, well-tailored, perhaps with details you like, is the way you should have gone in the first place.

The charcoal SC also limits your potential trouser matchings, but white sounds atrocious to me. If you must stick with it, though it's probably not totally SF-approved, I'd go with a white shirt, well-fitting black trousers, and black shoes and belt, white square, simple fold. It will be monochromatic, sort of the look you're going for, but much more elegant.

Buy a decent pair of shoes. Not zooty ones. Maybe just a pair of Allen Edmonds Park Avenues. And a good linen square. White button-down oxford. Make sure everything fits.

Have fun, good luck.
post #14 of 40
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jackinthebox View Post

Yes... you will stand out. As the guy who overdresses for the occasion. If nobody wears a suit, you are going a big statement then and there. Consider it's about the bride and the groom, not about you. 


If you want to dress sharp: good Chino/jeans, shirt and tie. Black shoes. You will be among the most elegantly dressed, yet you will not stand out with such a bold statement.

No, no and no. He's not talking about wearing a suit, so there's no issue there. A jacket without a tie or jacket with tie is not going to make him stand out if there are some other people wearing ties there. Also, tie with no jacket is just an awful look unless OP wants to look like an intern playing dress up. And chinos / jeans with a tie? WTF, really? This is a wedding for goodness sakes.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Logen View Post

Ok so just to answer a few things that came up here.
Yes the pants are really really white. The jacket is very dark, in some lighting you will almost confuse it with black. As for the shirt it's a light gray Calvin Klein.

And probably the most important part, no one is going to be wearing a suit. I think most people will just be with a dress shirt and slacks, maybe a few with a tie. The wedding is at night. So I do think I will stand out.

Why is this such a horrible combination?

You won't find a lot of love for grey odd jackets here, especially ones that are charcoal colored. They're just not very versatile. A slight off-white or cream color is more useful for trousers than pure white, which to me looks strange up against dark grey. It's like mixing a look from summer with one from winter. I can live with white linen personally but don't care for white trousers in any other material. And light grey dress shirts almost inevitably look cheap. If you had to change one thing in the outfit to make it look better, I'd go with a light blue, pink or lilac shirt in place of the grey. I'm not a huge fan of the charcoal odd jacket idea but I don't see many jackets looking great with the grey dress shirt. Also note that pink looks great with dark grey.

You will not stand out as overdressed in a jacket and no tie. If at least a few people are wearing jacket and tie (but not a suit), you will be fine in this. One would expect family of the bride and groom to be among the better dressed, so if you're dressed better than most, just make sure you don't outshine the bride and groom and you will be fine.
post #15 of 40
Quote:
Originally Posted by Douglas View Post

no offense, but your whole outfit sounds like a train wreck. it's probably why you're not getting much response.

This. Scrap your entire original notion and start over, honestly.

Nothing about the original outfit seems good.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Classic Menswear
Styleforum › Forums › Men's Style › Classic Menswear › Need help matching shoes, belt and pocket square